Feature image for The Right Stuff

The Right Stuff

Evaluating respect, partnership, interpersonal skills, and cultural fit can improve hiring decisions beyond standard qualifications.

3 min read

Photo Credit: No credit needed

In Part 1 last month, it was suggested that typical job-candidate selection methods may not adequately assess a prospective staffer’s internal and external job awareness--that is, the ability to recognize and rectify current problems, as well as an ability to imagine how the job may evolve. If these factors are overlooked, a newly hired staff member, while making a minimum contribution to the agency’s operation, may not strive for optimal performance. Part 2 addresses two additional under-assessed factors--respect and partnership.

Take The Time

During a standard interview, a manager likely reviews the agency’s formal structure and policies, but it is less likely that informal structure and culture--how things actually get done--are discussed. More often, a conceptual framework used to gauge a prospective employee’s past experiences in “getting along” with colleagues is not discussed..

It is one thing to talk about finding a good “fit” among current and new staff, and quite another to actually devote the time to identify and assess an employee’s existing interpersonal skills as well as compare those results to the candidate’s personal characteristics. (Each semester, my Human Resource (HR) management students conduct interviews with newly-hired staff about their respective agency’s HR practices. Rushed hiring and inadequate orientation invariably are among the most common complaints.) Some managers depend on standardized psychometric instruments, such as the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, and at the other end of the scale, other interviewers rely on gut instinct.